Thomas Aquinas, that grace builds on nature

Death Has Become a Choice

canada goose coats on sale In past weeks, two tragic end of life cases have caught national attention. One is the case of Jahi McMath and the other is the case of Marlise Munoz. Both McMath and Munoz remain on life support, but McMath’s parents want to keep their daughter connected to the ventilator, while the Munoz family wants the pregnant woman disconnected from any life sustaining interventions. Both cases are heart wrenching and both cases are also raising fundamental questions about how we understand death. Despite the tragedies of our everyday lives where people die in accidents or in violent acts, most people in the United States do not die simply. Today when most people die, they canada goose outlet sale do so because someone a loved one, a guardian, a physician makes a decision. canada goose coats on sale

cheap Canada Goose McMath is a 13 year old girl who was declared brain dead by doctors at Children’s Hospital in Oakland, Calif., yet a prolonged heartbeat has led McMath’s parents and family to the view that she is still alive. They live in hope of a miracle. McMath went in for surgery that most of us would consider “routine” a tonsillectomy to correct her problems with sleep apnea. But something had gone terribly wrong. McMath seemed to have suffered cardiac arrest and severe bleeding. After careful examination by the physicians, she was declared brain dead and the hospital sought to remove her from the ventilator. Her family fought back. Eventually, McMath was released to her family and transferred to another, unknown medical facility. cheap Canada Goose

uk canada goose outlet Munoz collapsed from a blood clot when she was 14 weeks pregnant. After examination and diagnosis, the cheap canada goose doctors at Peter Smith Hospital in Ft. Worth, Texas, have also pronounced her brain dead. In her case, however, the hospital has refused to remove the ventilator, as the family had requested, because it would harm (kill) the fetus, which is now in its 20th week. Texas law mandates that she be sustained for the well being of the fetus. uk canada goose outlet

canada goose uk outlet These are not the first cases that have raised ethical questions, particularly of how we understand death and brain death. Over the last 40 years, there have been many difficult cases that have led us to think about end of life issues. The cases bear the names of the patients involved: Quinlan, Brophy, Cruzan and Schiavo. But those patients, unlike McMath and Munoz, were not brain dead. They were in a persistently vegetative state. A persistently vegetative state means that a person has no higher cognitive awareness of what’s going on around them, yet the patient still has some brain stimulation. When a person is brain dead, all the parts of the brain are dead and these patients cannot maintain normal blood pressure or body temperature. canada goose factory outlet vancouver These patients would require medications and life support technology to keep them breathing. canada goose uk outlet

Canada Goose online It is important to remember that, at present, when the cells of the brain die they cannot be restored. Other organs, such as the heart, can be replaced through transplant surgery. This is not the case with the brain. When it is dead, it is dead. This reminds me of the maxim of St. Thomas Aquinas, that grace builds on nature. Aquinas’ point seems to be that God works through nature. canada goose outlet hong kong In nature, the brain is essential to who we are and what we do. And the biology of the brain is that when it is dead, it is dead. Canada Goose online

cheap canada goose uk The ethics and canada goose outlet new york city legality of the Munoz case is complicated by her pregnancy. We, in the United States, have a complex public policy towards pregnancy. On the one hand, if she were able, Munoz could have an abortion. But she didn’t. Before her collapse and brain death, she and her husband had made a decision to have a child. Texas, like at least 31 states, has a law restricting the ability of doctors to end life canada goose outlet in new york support for terminally ill pregnant women, regardless of the wishes of the patient or the family. cheap canada goose uk

Canada Goose Outlet This brings us to another ethical question that needs to be asked, but rarely is in America. What about the cost of care in these cases? In the United States, we pay for health care through either public or private insurance pools. Most experts would estimate the cost of the care received by brain dead patients to canada goose outlet eu be about $7,500 a day. Many people are contributing to their care. In a world of limited resources, which is the world we canada goose jacket outlet store live in, how resources are used is an ethical question. It is a question of stewardship. And, in a world of limited resources, every determination of where we use our canada goose outlet store toronto resources is also an implicit decision not to use them elsewhere. Canada Goose Outlet

Canada Goose Jackets The long term tragedy is that we will continue to see cases like this. As medical technologies develop and advance, we will be able to do more to sustain life. It is imperative that we recognize what we are doing and why. In the evolution of modern medicine, death has become canada goose outlet legit a choice. And those choices come with important moral responsibilities Canada Goose Jackets.


メールアドレスが公開されることはありません。 * が付いている欄は必須項目です